Did CBS just kill off CNET?

The news gathering business is full of tough calls every day, especially when there is both news and editorial content involved. There is always a very fine line to walk between what is news and what is editorial content. The public generally does not see the difference in cases like the “Best of Show” awards given by sites like ourselves and CNET. Last week we now know that CBS crossed a line that should never be crossed in journalism.

CNN is now reporting that after CNET announced its “Best of CES” candidates, the CBS corporate office “laid down a ban: CNET won’t be allowed to even review Dish products, much less give them awards.”

The page for CNET’s review of Hopper was also updated with a statement that “the Dish Hopper with Sling was removed from consideration for the Best of CES 2013 awards due to active litigation involving our parent company CBS Corp. We will no longer be reviewing products manufactured by companies with which we are in litigation with respect to such product.”

The story actually gets juicier when CNET tells their side of the story. Excerpted below is the account directly from CNET as reported by Lindsey Turrentine

Last week, about 40 members of the CNET editorial staff met in the CNET trailer in the parking lot of the Las Vegas Convention Center to vote on our official Best of CES winner. We gathered on Wednesday evening and heard from each editor covering the show what he or she liked best.

Ultimately, we chose the Dish Hopper for our Best of CES award because of innovative features that push shows recorded on DVR to iPads.
After the vote, we communicated the winners, as we always do, through normal channels. CNET immediately got down to the business of preparing for a massive stage show the following morning and preparing a press release.

Later that evening, we were alerted to the legal conflict for CBS. All night and through to morning, my managers up and down CNET and I fought for two things: To honor the original vote and — when it became clear that CBS Corporate did not accept that answer — to issue a transparent statement regarding the original vote.
Ultimately, we were told that we must use the official statement and that we must follow corporate policy to defer all press requests to corporate communications.

This is a completely untenable situation for the reporters and editors at CNET and quite possibly could mean the end of CNET as a respected news and opinion site. Respecter reporters are resigning in protest from CNET. The editor in chief for CNET reviews openly stated that maybe she should have immediately resigned. How is the public supposed to believe anything coming out of CNET anymore, or CBS for that matter. Does this mean that if they do not support a politician that they will not cover them? When it comes down to it what is the difference?

How can CBS possibly justify that? News organizations report news. Simply the fact that you are in litigation with a company MUST be reported on in an unbiased manner within your news organization and to do proper reporting you have to review the product enough to explain why you are in litigation.

These kinds of things have happened before sadly and the wall is dead between the corporate and news divisions amongst almost all of the major media players. That is why we do what we do and bring reporting that is not beholden to any corporate entities. We will never allow the money counters to interact with the news gatherers or editorial staff at SNFN.

You think this is not important? Think about it this way: AOL owns Engadget; NewsCorp owns The Wall Street Journal and its influential tech coverage; IAC invests in Aereo but owns The Daily Beast. If these corporate overlords are going to control editorial content, where will we get our news?

More on the web:

Amazon Auto-Rip… The future is here

AutoRipAmazon wants to make sure that CD buying customers are given access to their albums online and the company’s Auto Rip feature makes that happen.

Announced on Thursday the AutoRip feature allows customers to receive digital copies of new purchases for more than 50,000 albums. The program also offers AutoRip copies of CDs customers have purchased over the last 15 years, a timetable that coincides with the launch of Amazon’s Music Store and your Amazon storage limit is not affected by the company’s new program.

This is an interesting development copyright wise, as customers can now purchase a CD, give it to a friend or family member and then listen to their own MP3 copy of songs via the Amazon Cloud player.

This program depends a lot on the honesty of customers in general as a case can be made that CD’s can be bought on Amazon and returned to say Wal-Mart or gifted and you then have a free copy of the music.

It almost seems crazy when you put some thought into it. Is it great for the consumer, sure it is, but the music companies may have just made a deal that cost them a ton of money.

I am not really sure if the record companies had in mind exactly what Amazon is doing here as in some cases used cds bought on Amazon were auto-ripped for consumers. So if I buy a CD and Amazon auto-rips it to me, then I sell it back used on Amazon they then auto-rip it again for the secondary buyer theoretically there will be endless digital copies and the record companies will receive nothing from the secondary rips. This is not supposed to be happening, but there are literally dozens of reports online of this happening. Amazon marketplace sales are supposed to be not included, but if it does happen there are some issues that still need to be cleared up.

A big win for consumers.


Military judge delays Army GI's trial in WikiLeaks case to June 3 – Fox News

Military judge delays Army GI's trial in WikiLeaks case to June 3
Fox News
FORT MEADE, Md. – A military judge has pushed back the start of the trial for an Army private charged with leaking classified documents to the WikiLeaks website to June 3. Army Col. Denise Lind set the new trial date during a pretrial hearing at Fort Meade
Military judge shaves days from potential prison term for Army GI who leaked New York Daily News
Judge Says Harsh Detention Is Not Cause to Drop Charges in WikiLeaks CaseNew York Times
WikiLeaks: Bradley Manning was treated improperly in lockup, judge rulesChristian Science Monitor
The GuardianWired
all 1,114 news articles

Source: US News

Biden: We must 'take immediate action' on gun control – USA TODAY

Biden: We must 'take immediate action' on gun control
Vice President Joe Biden, with Attorney General Eric Holder at left, speaks during a meeting with victims' groups and gun safety organizations in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the White House complex in Washington, Wednesday, Jan. 9, 2013.
First Thoughts: Biden's gun violence listening sessions beginNBCNews.com
Wal-Mart will meet with Biden gun task force on ThursdayReuters
Wal-Mart to attend gun control meeting at White HouseCNN
Houston Chronicle
all 1,484 news articles

Source: US News

Startup Pebble Announces Ship Dates For Smart Watch – Wall Street Journal (blog)

Startup Pebble Announces Ship Dates For Smart Watch
Wall Street Journal (blog)
The startup behind the most successful Kickstarter fund-raising campaign ever, the Pebble smart watch, is finally providing its customers the one thing they've been asking for since July: a shipment date. Pebble Technology raised more than $10.2 million
Pebble smartwatch set to shipBBC News
The Pebble smartwatch keeps it simple (hands-on)The Verge
Pebble Watch Will Finally Ship on January 23All Things Digital
Gizmodo UKThe Next Web
all 12 news articles

Source: Tech Feed

Apple's Cheap iPhone Is A Great Move For The Company – Business Insider

Apple's Cheap iPhone Is A Great Move For The Company
Business Insider
At the end of this year, when Apple's cheap iPhone comes out, it is going to be amusing to listen to all the Apple fans who consoled themselves about Apple's loss of market share by dismissing competitors' phones as “cheap plastic crap.” Because the new
Rumors about cheaper Apple iPhone resurfaceWashington Post
Report Suggests Apple Will Launch a Cheaper iPhone in 2013Slide To Play
Apple defies Steve Jobs, eyes cheaper iPhoneMSN Money
CNETWall Street Journal (blog)Register
all 477 news articles

Source: Tech Feed

Kashmir shooting: India's Kurshid warns on escalation – BBC News

Kashmir shooting: India's Kurshid warns on escalation
BBC News
India has rebuked Pakistan over the alleged killing of two soldiers in the disputed territory of Kashmir but has warned against escalation of the dispute in the flashpoint region. India summoned Pakistan's top envoy in Delhi to express its outrage. Pakistan has
Tensions rise betwen nuclear neighbours Pakistan and IndiaTelegraph.co.uk
Leaders' momentIndian Express
India lashes Pakistan after deadly Kashmir encounterReuters
Hindustan TimesNDTVNPR (blog)
all 2,720 news articles

Source: World News

Wrinkles Help Wet Fingers Get a Grip – Wired

Wrinkles Help Wet Fingers Get a Grip
At the annual WIRED Business Conference: Disruptive by Design, we celebrate the creative power of bold new ideas and the people that make them happen. See the event > ? Security ? Danger Room ? What Did Google Earth Spot in the Chinese Desert?
Why We Get Wrinkly FingersBusiness Insider
Why Skin Wrinkles When WetDiscovery News
Science puts wrinkled fingers to the testBBC News
GizmodoThe GuardianSurferToday
all 70 news articles

Source: Science News

Samsung: 4K Ultra HD Content Will Come – Mashable

Samsung: 4K Ultra HD Content Will Come
LAS VEGAS — Samsung's massive 85-inch 4K Ultra HD TV is a thing of beauty. When you look at the screen, it's more like looking out a window — the images are that real. Even so, as we all watched Samsung introduce its latest line of cutting-edge
CES Highlight #1: Smart TVsForbes
How Samsung might actually get featuritis under controlCNET
LG Shows Gorgeous Curved OLED and Ultra HD TouchTom’s Hardware Guide
all 1,961 news articles

Source: Tech Feed

Bushfire battle extends to space – New Zealand Herald

Bushfire battle extends to space
New Zealand Herald
Operation to protect Australia from disaster ranges from volunteers on ground to high-tech satellite imagery. Photos of Australian bushfires taken by Commander Chris Hadfield from the International Space Station. Pictures / Chris Hadfield / NASA. Fire chiefs
Strange But True: Astronauts Get Taller in SpaceSpace.com
A disturbing glimpse of Australia's wildfires as seen from spaceio9
Astronaut beams down beautiful views from spaceNBCNews.com (blog)
MashableTelegraph.co.ukOttawa Citizen
all 92 news articles

Source: Science News